Fivestars alternative
SMS-based loyalty for local businesses (now SumUp). Below is the honest, positive-sum comparison — where Fivestars wins, where Wallefy wins, and how to decide.
Where Fivestars wins
Fivestars (acquired by SumUp) has 70M+ consumers in their network and a familiar in-store tablet experience. Businesses that want a phone-number-based punch system with merchant-facing tablet at checkout.
Where Wallefy wins
- Apple Wallet + Google Wallet passes (Fivestars uses phone number only — no wallet pass)
- Push notifications free (Fivestars uses SMS at ~$0.03 per message retail markup)
- RFM segmentation with 11 behavioral segments (Fivestars has basic visit tracking)
- Industry-tier calibration for service businesses (Fivestars is one-size-fits-all)
- No required hardware (Fivestars wants their tablet at every checkout)
Pricing
Fivestars charges per-message for SMS marketing on top of platform fees. Wallefy push is always free.
Frequently asked
Is Wallefy better than Fivestars?
Wallefy and Fivestars solve different problems. Fivestars (acquired by SumUp) has 70M+ consumers in their network and a familiar in-store tablet experience. Wallefy wins when you need wallet-first loyalty, RFM segmentation, industry-tier-calibrated automations, and POS-agnostic integration.
How much does Wallefy cost vs Fivestars?
Fivestars charges per-message for SMS marketing on top of platform fees. Wallefy push is always free.
Can I migrate from Fivestars to Wallefy?
Yes. Wallefy accepts customer-list CSV imports from Fivestars and any other loyalty platform. Existing customers map automatically to the RFM segmentation engine.
See your personalized Wallefy plan in 90 seconds
Free. No signup. Pulls your real menu/services + industry-tier-calibrated recommendations.
Build My Free Growth Plan